About a month or so ago, I heard some buzz about a great Secret Santa opportunity in the blog world. Apparently, there was a cookie swap being planned. And a cookie swap is something you don’t have to tell me about twice.
I immediately signed up for the Food Blogger Cookie Swap, which was run by Love and Olive Oil along with The Little Kitchen. These girls put in such hard work to make sure everyone had matches — I have to say, it was incredibly organized.

So, how did it work?
1. You signed up to be a part of the swap, including your mailing address and any dietary restrictions you might have.
2. By a certain date, the organizers emailed you three matches who you baked 1 dozen cookies per person.
3. You mail those three people their cookies.
4. In return, three people were also assigned YOUR name, meaning you get three dozen cookies in the mail.
It is only mandatory that I tell you I have been eating cookies non stop for the last two days.
I received my three packages over the course of the past few days and every single dozen I received is nothing less than stellar.
The first package I received was from Becca.
The second I received this package, I tore into a cookie and muttered a statement of disbelief. Honestly, when I am buried, I want to bring these cookies with me. They are dense nuggets of sugary goodness, and I have been joyfully eating one (or two) every night after dinner. I tried putting them in the freezer to make them last longer (read: so I would stop living off of cookies for a day or two), but the good/bad news is they taste excellent frozen. Win, win or lose, lose?
Now would also be the time you DON’T comment on my nasty fingernails.
The second package I got was from Maria @ GF Girl in Chicago.
Maria sent me White Sugar Cookies with Pecans, and it would be a total lie if I told you I have not been crumbling these into my oats in the morning. Who says you can’t eat cookies for breakfast? I sure wouldn’t want to be friends with them.
These cookies are crisp and crunchy, but thick — just the way sugar cookies should be in my book. I want another one just looking at this picture.
The last package I got was from Julie @Â Swim, Bike, Running on Empty.
Julie baked Nutty Chocolate Pumpkin Bits — and they are delicious! They are moist and chewy, almost cake like and so good!
Now, in my opinion, I am absolutely convinced that this whole cookie swap thing should not just be during the holidays. I’m thinking something monthly if we can work it out… however, I’m pretty sure my pants won’t like me (or I won’t like them) if that were to happen.
Thanks for the goodies girls!
Question: What is your favorite holiday cookie?













{ 50 comments… read them below or add one }
Uh. Makin those. So many cookies are WAY better frozen, I see it as an accidental blessing.
agreed.
And now I’m kicking myself for not signing up for this! Holy yum! The favorite cookie question is just impossible to answer. I pretty much like them all! Although, ones with liquor in them are kind of nice this time of year
anything with liquor in it is good.
My stomach is so sad that I missed this!
Oh wow all those cookies look delicious! I’m craving some cookies now. I definitely know what I’ll be doing tomorrow: Me + Kitchen = Cookies
I love soft gingerbread…but really all cookies are my fav
I got my first batch of cookies from the swap yesterday but haven’t tried any yet…tonight for sure
I hope they’re delicious!
oh this makes me sad cause i remember getting your wonderful cookies last year and now i can’t particiapte in the exchange. Bummer. When i get back to the states, i might have to get those recipes!
till march.
i LOVED the cookie swap! i received 3 batches of ridiculously delicious cookies (heavy on the chocolate… a definite plus). and i’m with you on a monthly version
Chocolate cookies are the best - and I always forget to tell you that your gravatar looks very similar to one of my friends, so every time I look at it, I always think it’s my friend Courtney!
I wish I’d known about this! All those cookies would make amazing study snacks.
My favourite holiday cookie is my Nana’s shortbread recipe. They seriously just melt in your mouth!
My favorite are sugar cookies with frosting!!!
I know this is the worst, but I loved those sugar cookies with the frosting that you buy at jewel. They are so so good.
omg so good…
How sweet…. I do the freezer thing too! Total toss up if it is a win-win or a lose-lose. How sweet of the girls, they sound pretty darn delicious!
My favorite is definitely shortbread!
It’s hard to pick a favorite. My mom makes batches and batches but I’m going to have to say I like her twist on the peanut blossom. She makes chocolate peanut blossoms and uses the peppermint kisses on top. Yum!
Almond cookies- with almond extract and ground almonds in the dough and then ROLLED in almonds. Mmmmmm….
What kind(s) of cookies did you send out?
You’ll have to wait and see until I post the recipe!
I hate when cookies taste just as good frozen.
the only thing bad about going to a tropical island for dec is not being able to participate in the cookie swaps..and im dead serious.
it pained me knowing i was missing out on linsday/julie’s swap b/c yes I am sure it was incredibly well run and everyone involved…total class acts. total class cookie acts. yum!
ha! I definitely believe that you were very upset.
Such a cute idea! Sad I missed it
Peanut butter kisses are my absolute favorite!!
Oh wow they all look so good! I’m officially jealous!
Those all look delicious! One of my favorites is our family recipe for Tassies - they are like mini pecan pies and are soooo good!
And you’re going to send me some, right?
Wow, what a great mix of cookies!
My favorite holiday cookies are these brazilian nut/coffee cookies that my Mom makes every year!
Recipe? That sounds so so good!
Yum! Those white sugar pecan cookies look so good!
I don’t know if I have a favorite holiday cookie. I just love them all!
how fun that you got three totally different cookies!!
these look fantastic!! man oh man, if i had these options of cookies in my house, they’d be devoured way too quickly! it looks like you got a perfect mix of some different kinds too!
ok, so i can’t only pick ONE favorite holiday cookie… but a few of my favorites include: no bake PB & chocolate oatmeal cookies, chocolate snowballs, and FUDGE! i don’t care if fudge isn’t a “cookie”, it still counts in my book.
I LOVE no bake cookies! THey’re the best.
Sugar cookies with hardened frosting scream the holidays for me! This cookie swap sounds like a genius idea!!
Yum! All the cookies look great!
My favorite holiday cookies are ginger cookies! I love them so much, especially with a little cream cheese frosting! I love super soft cookies as well, where they just melt right into your mouth!!!
Thanks to you, I’m now craving a delicious cookie!
Maybe my holiday baking will have to start this weekend!!!
Wow, those look incredible! But then, I’m pretty much a sucker for cookies in general. My favorites are classic chocolate chip and peanut butter. But for the holidays I try and get a bit more adventurous with some sort of mint, pumpkin, or gingerbread flavors. As long as they are gluten-free they are good with me!
If you ever organize a monthly cookie swap… I will be the first to sign up. And cookies for breakfast are definitely legit.
Fun!!!!! I love cookies and I love giving
I love anything with Chocolate and Mint!!! SWOOOOON!!
xxoo
My coffee has chocolate and mint this morning!
What a perfect way to celebrate the holidays! All three cookies look and sound sensational.
Chocolate+Mint=Heaven! And you can never go wrong when pumpkin is involved.
Oooo cookie exchange. My favorite is a good ol chewy sugar cookie with frosting. I also was introduced to saltine toffee last year, and it is pretty much Christmas crack. I pinned this recipe for peanut butter pretzel bites, and am planning to make them tomorrow (http://twotinykitchens.com/2011/02/23/peanut-butter-pretzel-bites/).
Those look so so good - too bad all GF pretzels out there have corn flour!
Oh how yum! Favourite cookie? hmm.. probably gingerbread
But those chocolate puddle drop cookies look unreal!!
Oh the cookie swap that I SHOULD of joined in! The cookies you got look amazing, now Im craving cookies with my coffee!
Happy Weekend ! xo
Ooh soooo good - I just got the one match because I’m in Canada and have the whole ‘natural sweeteners only’ thing so there was only one person who matched that requirement wanting to ship to Canada, but I cannot wait for their cookies to get here! So excited!
What a great idea!! I used to love those store-bought shortbread cookies. They’re just so addictive! And 1 serving per bag, by my calculations.
My favourite cookie recipe is for no-bake peanut butter/chocolate cookies, the kind that people sometimes add coconut to (and thereby ruin them). I want to try the Puddle cookies so badly! yum!!